At The Pen and Paper Society, we believe the most powerful stories aren’t just read—they are experienced. Our collections unfold through beautifully crafted letters, telegrams, clippings, and keepsakes, drawing you into the worlds of unforgettable characters and the moments that define them.
About Us
About Us
About The Pen and Paper Society
From sweeping romances and edge-of-your-seat mysteries to whimsical adventures and spine-tingling horrors, every series is meticulously researched, hand-designed, and mailed straight to your door. Two letters a month, you’ll follow an intimate correspondence that makes you feel like you’ve stumbled across someone’s private world—because in a way, you have.
This isn’t ordinary mail. This is a story you’ll hold in your hands, one you’ll savor, display, and remember.
Welcome to The Pen and Paper Society—where your mailbox becomes the doorway to another time, another place, another life
Romance Series
When the Sky Was Ours, Home to You, Whiskey Kisses & Gunpowder Promises, Yours Til the Cannons Fade, Dear James, and so on as the stories go….
At The Pen and Paper Society, we believe love stories are meant to be felt, not just read. Our romance collections arrive as intimate letters and keepsakes, each one a piece of an unfolding tale between unforgettable characters.
Delivered right to your mailbox, our stories invite you to slow down, pour a cup of tea, and lose yourself in a world where every word feels meant for you.
Your love story starts here – open the first letter.
Mystery & Adventure Series
Indiana Series, Prohibition, Dear James, and select cross-genre sets…
The Pen and Paper Society takes you inside mysteries you can touch, hold, and unravel at your own pace. Every collection arrives as a series of letters, telegrams, maps, and clues—each one drawing you deeper into the story.
From dangerous speakeasies to forgotten tombs, cross-country races to whispered espionage, you’ll follow the trail just as the characters do, discovering secrets one envelope at a time
This isn’t just reading. It’s stepping into the shoes of someone living the adventure, with your mailbox as the gateway.
The first clue is waiting—will you follow it?
Gothic & Dark Academia Series
Bloodlines and Broken Seals, Until the Veins Run Dry, Nightsong Series…
At The Pen and Paper Society, we believe some stories are better told in ink, candlelight, and shadows. Our gothic collections are steeped in atmosphere—each letter a whispered secret, each keepsake a fragment of a forbidden past.
You’ll wander haunted manors, linger in candlelit libraries, and uncover truths that were never meant to see the light. Every detail, from the paper texture to the seal, is designed to pull you deeper into the world until you forget where your own ends.
These aren’t just stories—they’re invitations into worlds where beauty and danger dance in the same breath
The candle is lit, the letter is sealed—will you cross the threshold?
Psychological Horror & Scare Mail
Someone Is Watching, Whispers from the Black Vale, and much, much more…
The Pen and Paper Society’s Scare Mail series is not for the faint of heart. Every letter is a descent—into paranoia, obsession, and the chilling certainty that something is out there… and it knows your name.
You won’t simply read the story. You’ll feel it: the unease creeping in with each envelope, the tension building as the letters close in. Some come stained, some corrupted, others containing fragments of something you’ll wish you hadn’t seen
It’s immersive horror you can hold in your hands, where the line between fiction and reality blurs—one delivery at a time.
They’re still writing to you… open it if you dare
Detective Book Collection
Adventures Beyond the Neverwoods, Letters from Nevermore Hollow and on to never ending imaginative stories…
The Pen and Paper Society’s whimsical collections turn your mailbox into a doorway to magical worlds. Every letter is a new adventure, sent by curious fairies, brave explorers, or mischievous creatures you’ll want as pen pals forever.
Inside each envelope, you’ll find stories, activities, and surprises designed to spark imagination—perfect for children, families, and anyone who still believes in wonder.
Because sometimes, the most magical journeys begin with a simple piece of mail
The map is drawn, the adventure awaits—come join the fun.
Nightsong Series
A Forbidden Correspondence
An intimate, adult-only letter series from The Pen and Paper Society
In Nightsong, the reader is drawn into a secret exchange of letters between two lovers bound bypassion, distance, and danger. Their relationship begins with subtle intrigue but grows into an erotic,
all-consuming connection told through ink-stained pages. Each letter is laced with forbidden desire,whispered confessions, and the ache of wanting what one should not have.
The map is drawn, the adventure awaits—come join the fun
And when you reach the final page, remember: this is not an ending. It is only the beginning. Welcome to Nightsong.
Reconnecting
In an age of instant messages and vanishing notifications, there’s something extraordinary about holding a real letter in your hands. The paper, the texture, the weight—it’s a piece of someone’s world sent directly to yours.
At The Pen and Paper Society, we believe mail has the power to slow us down, to make us linger on each word, and to connect us in ways no screen ever could. Each envelope you open is a reminder that connection doesn’t have to be rushed—it can be savored.
These are stories you’ll not only read, but keep. Letters you’ll tuck away in boxes, revisit on rainy days, and pass along to someone you love. Because the joy of receiving mail isn’t just about what’s inside—it’s about feeling a human connection, one letter at a time
Thank you. ~Kathryn, founder
Our Mission
At The Pen and Paper Society, we believe in the power of stories to spark joy, inspire curiosity, and bring people closer together. Every letter we send is an invitation—to pause, to imagine, and to connect with the people and worlds that matter most.